Case against marine mammals in captivity world animal protection. Erich hoyt born 28 september 1950 is a whale and dolphin cetacean researcher, conservationist, lecturer and author of 22 books and more than 600 reports, articles and papers. Relevant legislation marine mammal law in the united states. This page is part of a larger humane society web site that includes a more general consideration of the state of marine mammals in the world at large, and a specific, downloadable pdf document arguing that the very nature of these animals makes them uniquely unsuited to confinement. Marine mammals are a part of nature and should not be bought, sold or thrown in an aquarium. Marine mammal welfare addresses the welfare effects of marine debris, of human traffic in the oceans, of noise, of hunting, of whale watching and tourism, and of some of the less obvious impacts on marine mammals on their social structures, on their behaviours and migration, and also of the effects on captivity for animals kept in zoos and. Check back tomorrow for the flip side of this controversial argument. Marine mammal welfare, human induced change in the marine environment and its impacts on marine mammal welfare has a large section dedicated to whales, dolphins and porpoises which takes a look at issues such as whaling, entanglement in fishing nets and captivity and examines the impacts that these activities have on the welfare, or wellbeing. Evolutionary biology, third edition is a succinct, yet comprehensive text devoted to the systematics, evolution, morphology, ecology, physiology, and behavior of marine mammals earlier editions of this valuable work are considered required reading for all marine biologists concerned with marine mammals, and this text continues that tradition of excellence with updated.
Marine mammal adaptation to an aquatic lifestyle varies considerably between species. An increasing number of scientists counter this view and believe that. Captive breeding programs are the center of quite a bit of controversy when it comes to animal conservation. In the past, animal capture was a violent and traumatic process. Marine mammals are kept captive for different reasons. I think the mandate, quite to the contrary, is very strong for the future. Seaworlds announcement in march that it would stop breeding killer whales marked a turning point for the marine park industry and the anticaptivity movement. Williamson c 2006 marine mammalsguidelines and criteria associated with captivity. The question if marine mammals should be kept in captivity is tough to answer. The most commonly known environmental law is the endangered species act esa of 1973.
The case against marine mammals in captivity animal. The park, the first attraction in the united states devoted to marine animals, opened in 1938 to. The pros of marine mammal captive breeding programs. This is the first book to summarize modern research on this subject, and it. If the animal is injured and cannot take care of itself in the wild, then, yes they should be kept in captivity. However, if the animal is taken out of its marine home for no reason then it should not be in captivity. A list of contributors and a brief biographic sketch of each author are provided at the end of the book.
It is one of four living species of the order sirenia, which also includes three species of manatees. Why whale and dolphin captivity is cruel the science. This book is a great comprehensive look marine mammal biology that covers a lot of areas. In summary, this book has synthesized existing data on conservation and management of. The case against marine mammals in captivity by the humane. Developing standards of care for marine mammals in captivity. Thompson, and charlotte kirk baer is published by university of chicago press.
Conservation and management of marine mammals journal of. Recommended reading imata international marine animal. To recognize variations on a theme, one must first recognize the theme. Death at seaworld shamu and the dark side of killer whales in captivity. Rosen is an expert in the physiological and behavioural ecology of marine mammals, with a bsc in marine biology and msc and phd degrees in. How dolphinariums, marine mammal parks and aquarium shows.
His book marine protected areas for whales, dolphins and porpoises. Watch 50 years of marine mammal captivity takepart. Marine mammals are aquatic mammals that rely on the ocean and other marine ecosystems for their existence. Blackfish stopped here by first of its kind marine. They include animals such as seals, whales, manatees, sea otters and polar bears. She is currently president of the whale sanctuary project, whose mission is to create the first seaside sanctuaries for orcas and beluga whales in north america, and founder and executive director of the kimmela center for animal advocacy, which focuses on bridging the. It doesnt matter what seaworld calls itto the orcas who will still be forced to perform in shows, captivity is captivity. Orcas have been in captivity since 1961, the first was for marineland of the pacific, who captured a female orca and when they introduced her to. But is there a way to proceed to resolve this issue based on evidence for whether cetaceans can thrive in marine parks and aquariums. Also, examine which other entities benefit from keeping marine mammals in captivity e. First, the water of the tank can cause serious health risks. By presenting a conservationbiology approach and new and emerging technologies, this work helps provide crucial knowledge on the status of marine mammal populations that not only helps readers. In the ethical debate over marine mammals in captivity there are many conflicting views. Impacts of multiple stressors on population health provides tactics on how to develop a comprehensive methodology for the study of existing threats to marine mammals.
It is the only living representative of the oncediverse family dugongidae. A dolphin swims past the viewing windows of a tank at marineland of florida near st. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading death at seaworld. The evolution of whale and dolphin captivity in the u. It also offers a framework for their future course, reaffirming that if zoos and aquariums. In his book the ethics of science, david resnik highlights eight.
In my opinion there is no doubt that marine mammals should not be held in captivity. Marine mammal inventory report killer whales orcinus orca in captivity an evaluation of marine mammal inventory recordkeeping for killer whales in captivity and adherence to marine mammal protection act mmpa requirements. The ongoing debate over whether cetaceans should be kept in captivity is relatively recent in contrast to the history of humanmarine mammal interactions. Lori marino the whale sanctuary project back to nature. The truth is that the overwhelming majority of marine mammal species currently being bred in captivity is neither threatened nor endangered. This chapter describes the origin and early evolution of cetaceans. Canada bans keeping whales and dolphins in captivity parliament passed the ending the captivity of whales and dolphins act in a move hailed by animal rights activists. Guest blog written by environmental visual communication student adil darvesh. Marine mammal welfare human induced change in the marine.
Lori marino is a neuroscientist and expert in animal behavior and intelligence, formerly on the faculty of emory university. It was just the latest milestone in the long history of displaying marine mammals for entertainment, from flippy, the first performing dolphin, to shamu, seaworlds famous killer whale. The case against marine mammals in captivity world animal. Marine animal captivity end the exploitation sociology essay.
The captive display industry is not static, and neither is our report, the case against marine mammals in captivitya forceful, evidencedriven argument against the public display of dolphins, whales, and other marine mammals, which the humane society of the united states first published in 1995. Study finds many marine mammals dying in captivity. Kirby lays out a compelling scientific argument against killer whale captivity. The first book of dolphins on free shipping on qualified orders. Create a list of typical statements made by parties who want marine mammal captivity to continue. She arrived in the area in 1984 as a whale researcher, and at first, she was. The larger animals represented a greater profit, so small marine mammals such as dolphins were mostly considered to be pests to fishermen. New student text book about marine mammals launched. Orcas, whether wildborn or captivebred, cannot thrive in captivity, says naomi rose, a marine mammal scientist at the animal welfare institute, a nonprofit organization based in. The final chapter describes the marinemammal conservation principles and their implementation. The dedicated efforts of experts and advocates, scientists, former trainers, and organizations like the humane society, awi, and immp, have not only changed the attitudes of. We recognize the fundamental relationship that binds humans, animals, and the ocean marine mammal center.
International marine mammal rescue is a group of professionals who have extensive expereince in the field of marine mammal rescue, rehabilitation, and. Shamu and the dark side of killer whales in captivity kindle edition by kirby, david. Canada bans keeping whales and dolphins in captivity. Their website won me over when it stated, what we do is more than kindhearted consideration for the wellbeing of other living creatures. One of which is the fact that orcas or so called killer whales can swim about 100 miles in 24 hours, these creatures can also go deep underwater about 500 ft. In his book the ethics of science, david resnik high lights eight factors. Dolphin and whale cetacean captivity is one of the most contentious cultural issues of modern times. Marine mammals guidelines and criteria associated with captivity september 2006 1.
This is the first of a twopart series exploring the positive and negative side of captive breeding programs for marine mammals. Marine mammals in captivity from the humane society of the united states. The public theme park industries advocate that marine mammal exhibits provide an important role in educating, entertaining, and conservation. Document produced as by the whale and dolphin conservation society, wdcs in collaboration with the spawrac and the cep secretariat for the protocol concerning specially protected areas and wildlife spaw in the wider caribbean. The case against marine mammals in captivity was first produced in 1995 as a comprehensive resource for the public, the media, scientists, students, and policymakers to learn the various arguments against holding marine mammals for public display in zoos, aquaria, and marine theme parks. Hoyt wrote the first book on whale watching, the whale watchers handbook. Principles and techniques for zoo management, second edition, edited by devra g.
This act was designed to prevent threatened and endangered species from becoming extinct by protecting them and their habitats. Developing standards of care for marine mammals in captivity 6 committee members dr. Ethical issues of keeping marine mammals in captivity. Should humans keep marine mammals in captivity for the sake of education and entertainment. Blackfish stopped here by first of its kind marine mammal law that legislators recently changed. Read about how dolphinariums, marine mammal parks and aquarium shows all cause deep emotional, physical and psychological suffering for orcas, dolphins and marine mammals. It reads like a scientific paper, so beware if youre looking for something. In november 2016, qila and aurora, two beluga whales at vancouver aquarium, died due to an unknown toxin in their tanks. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets.
1518 608 1129 1160 567 889 920 226 1162 322 1185 603 885 670 1282 1010 1517 841 254 520 99 1064 1405 753 371 1100 1050 279 742 432 278 589 928 984 1293 381 775 189